The Forum › Everything Else FileCabi.net Forum (2007–2008)

Theives in China Get a Disturbing Beatdown

This topic was the comments for this video (the video itself was lost).

Salvaged from archive These posts were salvaged from the web archive of the original FileCabi forum (2007–2008). Usernames are as they were then and aren’t linked to today’s accounts.

FileCabi.netSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 19:16
Theives in China Get a Disturbing Beatdown (http://www.filecabi.net/video/g39090-qqq.html)
K-LabSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 20:33
I don't give a fuck what they stole.they did not deserve 99 percent of that beating.Those people who hit them with cement blocks are the real criminals and are the ones that should get a beating like that and then some.Bunch of fucking cowards taking advantage of the chance to brutally beat some people.
j7wildSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 20:39
well at the beginning the two Suspects were on the ground and they were not handcuffed or restrained and there was only one person attacking them; why didn't they fight back or run? You couldn't do this in the U.S. and get away with it; Self Defense and use of Violence to protect your Property can only get you so far.
asdfSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 20:45
That was a serious beating. You can be executed in China for less than stealing.
gwaneSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 20:48
Goo0000ooot DAME !!! all that over some rice cakes!!!!
The JokerSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 20:51
i liked how they smashed his fingers with the cement block...classic
OmigoshSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 21:37
Poetic justice. People commit crimes because they know they'll either get away with it, or have a very minor punishment. Maybe they'll think twice stealing in china.
JINXERSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 21:42
I wish they had that kind of justice here in the usa....
RezohSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 21:46
What have you learned today ? Don't steal in China :rolleyes:
limboslamSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 21:52
I don't give a fuck what they stole.they did not deserve 99 percent of that beating.Those people who hit them with cement blocks are the real criminals and are the ones that should get a beating like that and then some.Bunch of fucking cowards taking advantage of the chance to brutally beat some people. Waaaaaaaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaaaaaa!
vilecabi.netSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 22:01
What I dont understand -- why didnt they just run?
AlexKSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 22:12
It does seem like very severe punishment but I've been to China and I've seen their culture. They don't like to follow rules and break them at any opportunity. Just try to cross a street there, it's insanity. I'm not knocking them, it's just their culture. Maybe they need strict discpline just to keep the peace. I saw a sign there in a seedy area that said a bunch of stuff in chinese and had a picture of a chinese general in uniform. In english it said "ALL CRIMES SEVERLY PUNISHED!".
HornetHandlerSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 22:44
That's why the crime rate in China is so low. Not saying they deserve it at all.
Jimmy_JamesSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 23:17
Thays why I keep my ass in Australia.
AsskickerSalvaged from archive5 Apr 2007, 23:30
At first I was thinking OK but then the punishers are acting much worse than the offenders. It's clear as if they are taking out all the past problems, financially speaking, on those few individuals and as if it is going to solve the "problem". They need someone to tell them "have you ever heard of overreacting?". I mean use a bamboo caining instead, not permanent damaging bricks! Next thing you know those brick throwers are going to accidentally step on someone's toe then get shot all because of that.
RhomphaiaSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:09
While I don't have any sympathy for the thieves (these guys, due to their mode of dress, looked far from destitute), this beating was over the line. Still, this is China, and these guys might be thought of as lucky they got off with this and not a couple of years of human rights violations in a chinese prison.
RaidenatorSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:29
While I don't have any sympathy for the thieves (these guys, due to their mode of dress, looked far from destitute), this beating was over the line. Still, this is China, and these guys might be thought of as lucky they got off with this and not a couple of years of human rights violations in a chinese prison. I don't have much sympathy for criminals either, but I think the one guy in the blue shirt was doing nothing more than taking out aggression. He seemed to be the most angry of the bunch, I doubt he was punishing them. Oh woops, I didn't see the part where you said the beating was over the line, my bad.
GaMer_G0dSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:30
So many fucking liberals here wah wah they didnt deserve that wah! Jesus now you people know why crime is so low in china and why it is so high in the USA. Its because of douches like these cry babies complain so criminals can get away with whatever they want. Ill bet you they wont ever steal again, where as here about 90 percent of the people who go to prison get out commit the same crime and then go back to prison :mad2:
k1ngSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:31
That was brutal.
RaidenatorSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:38
So many fucking liberals here wah wah they didnt deserve that wah! Jesus now you people know why crime is so low in china and why it is so high in the USA. Its because of douches like these cry babies complain so criminals can get away with whatever they want. Ill bet you they wont ever steal again, where as here about 90 percent of the people who go to prison get out commit the same crime and then go back to prison :mad2: We have a right here, it's called the Eighth Amendment. "No man will be subject to cruel or unusual punishment." Granted, this is China, but that was still just too far. TBH I would even feel a bit better if it were the police doing it, but these citizens just took it too far.
bigballerSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:44
Goo0000ooot DAME !!! all that over some rice cakes!!!! wow, your post had a hint of racism in it! interesting how you of all people would spout out something racist! about the video... 1) I'm glad I live in the US 2) I bet these guys won't be stealing from that guy again
gwaneSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 00:47
I wish they had that kind of justice here in the usa.... dud do you really think anyone in the US would have stood for that shit ?!?! Dud I would have come back and shot everyone standing there that looked liked the kicked me ..
aznlilboizSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 01:23
that is pretty normal to me, a small city, small town, or very small village, they has their own way of laws, they never fellow laws outside of their village.
sokule10Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 01:24
OMFG!! as soon as they brought out those fuckin cinder blocks i literally had to bite my fingers to stop myself from yelling out, that was just some truly fucked up shit. i havent seen anything so graphic before and i thought id seen some nasty shit
c stylez 360Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 01:41
Hardcore...
simplelifedreamSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 01:47
I've live in China for many years, this is just typical scene, you may not see it everyday, but it is definitly not unusual. No one on the street care to stop. Many thoughts that China has became more civilize in recent years, it is true. However, majority of China still has a lot to catch up.
deathfromaboveSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 02:03
Those guys went over the line, im sure they could of handled the situation with less dramatic terms of punishment. They defiantly have there share of over dramatic stupid people as any other country does. im sure karma will take its turn.
HiFiRSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 02:24
that's why you have to get a stronger body and fight back, at least kill one of them before you get killed.
JegarSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 02:32
For fucks sake! That was fucking messed up, especially when they threw cement blocks on them :O
JegarSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 02:33
What I dont understand -- why didnt they just run? Store owner maybe catched up with them and took 'em down pretty hard...?
anmp5sitsSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 03:05
If we had that kind of justice here, 90 percent of our criminals would be dead! So many morons in the USA scream and cry about how bad they have it here. Especially criminals on the street, in prison etc. WE NEED TO SEND ALL OUR CRIMINALS TO CHINA, SO THEY KNOW HOW GOOD THEY HAVE IT HERE!
RhomphaiaSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 03:34
So many fucking liberals here wah wah they didnt deserve that wah! Jesus now you people know why crime is so low in china and why it is so high in the USA. Its because of douches like these cry babies complain so criminals can get away with whatever they want. Ill bet you they wont ever steal again, where as here about 90 percent of the people who go to prison get out commit the same crime and then go back to prison :mad2: You see, it is the line between 'crime and punishment' and barbarity. Something tells me this mobbing was not about thievery, but something else. What that may be I don't know, even though I have some good guesses. However well deserved, this beating was barbaric. By definition, any beating that takes place to hurt someone as much as possible is barbaric. Sometimes the barbarism is deserved, most of the time it is not and I feel that thievery is not one of those times. Banishment, time in jail, whatever (perhaps even cutting off of a hand in extreme cases) would all suffice. A disorganized beating like this is not warranted. However, like I said above, something tells me this wasn't just about somebody stealing something. The crowd wanted these men hurt and hurt badly. I can't think of a common thief evoking that sort of wide response.
RaidenatorSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 03:37
You see, it is the line between 'crime and punishment' and barbarity. Something tells me this mobbing was not about thievery, but something else. What that may be I don't know, even though I have some good guesses. However well deserved, this beating was barbaric. By definition, any beating that takes place to hurt someone as much as possible is barbaric. Sometimes the barbarism is deserved, most of the time it is not and I feel that thievery is not one of those times. Banishment, time in jail, whatever (perhaps even cutting off of a hand in extreme cases) would all suffice. A disorganized beating like this is not warranted. However, like I said above, something tells me this wasn't just about somebody stealing something. The crowd wanted these men hurt and hurt badly. I can't think of a common thief evoking that sort of wide response. Hells yeah! I agree pretty well completely Rhomp. That's really what I was getting at.
MightyTinySalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 03:53
So many fucking liberals here wah wah they didnt deserve that wah! Jesus now you people know why crime is so low in china and why it is so high in the USA. Its because of douches like these cry babies complain so criminals can get away with whatever they want. Ill bet you they wont ever steal again, where as here about 90 percent of the people who go to prison get out commit the same crime and then go back to prison :mad2: Please explain to me then why, in the Scandinavian countries, where punishments are much more lenient than in the US, and no death penalty, are crime rates far, far lower than in the US? A beating like in this video was highly excessive, and showed exactly what's wrong with vigilante "justice". I'm all for locking up chid molestors and violent murderers for life, but getting beaten within an inch of your life by a mob in vigilante "justice" style for stealing... I'm dismayed to see that there are people that seem OK with it.
CuddleSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 04:14
in all honesty i'd be very surprised if either of those men sruvived through the night..i saw a few fierce body blows from that cinder block that would have probably caused massive internal bleeding..regardless, that's why you don't steal kiddies! OH PLLEEAAASEE!! PLLEEAASSEE DONT HURT ME! I only stole from your business which is what provides food for you family and contributed to driving you into financial hell! please let me off with a slap on the wrist!
twiconSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 04:44
they ''baptised'' 2 brand new serial killers... at least i would turn to
lochackSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 04:55
This nothing compared to Middle Eastern country's where they cut your hands off and sometimes your dick.
MortelloSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 05:02
Still I question if the Chinese are as bad or not as bad as the Soviets. What do you think, filecabi? Worse, Less, or Rivals in dealing with civil matters?
silenthill22Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 05:19
damn broke the rock...i mean..damn they took a beaten! shouldn't have been thieving i guess :rolleyes: That was one sadistic fuck. He wasn't even pissed about being robbed. He was just getting his jollies off doing that to them.
ColossusSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 06:07
OMFG!! as soon as they brought out those fuckin cinder blocks i literally had to bite my fingers to stop myself from yelling out, that was just some truly fucked up shit. i havent seen anything so graphic before and i thought id seen some nasty shit Ohh Boy!! you're in for a treat, if you think that's brutal let me introduce you to the videos that change my attitude towards humans and life as i use to know it. First you have to watch "Faces of Death" I and II just to prepare yourself for the horror of the famous "Traces of Death" series, it goes from 1 to 4 episodes, you may find some clips of the series around the net, there are at least 2 clips from those series in every multimedia site, there's even one here on "Filecaby" the one that executes an african man or something like that. I remenber renting those videos in "Video Ave." wen i was 17 and i remember having a happy concept of the world and how great the world was until i watch in AWE the real human behavior around the world, i had a system crash for like two weeks and i couldn't think of something else, couldn't get those images out of my head either and that was a wile back i'm 27 now, and those videos were like the underground videos of that time since there were nothing like it, not even on the net and the first of all underground videos dating even back than "Faces of Death" was "Holocaust Cannibal" this title was use years later for a movie but it wasn't related to the real underground video (but they remake some parts of it) it was so old that i didn't have a chance to see it becuz it was put out of the video stores wen i was a child but one friend of mine who's 39 now seen it and said it was a crew of a television network that were making a documental about some tribes and they get too close, but here is the kicker!, wen the Cannibals notice the strange white devils (the reporters) the Whole village wen into an anbush to capture the reporters so the camara man drop the camera in the middle of the village to run for safety and it keep recording wile the cannibals pick them up and take them away, the cannibals even pick at the camera with sticks like if they were afraid of the camara. Wen the network didn't hear from the crew they send back up and find the camara and a few hours of video with the brutal images. then the rescue crew even find the burn bones of the reporters in poles like if they were eaten and this info came from the intro at the begining of the tape so myb the network play the the tape in a private session and want it destroyed but the editor in the network have other plans for it $$$ and that's how myb the video got out. :2twocents: "Sorry for the long story":o
GrugSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 06:21
And that's why you never steal from Jet Li kids!
GrugSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 06:23
Fuck that! I turned that one off about a 3rd of the way through - there a some things I don't ever want to see. That was sick.
matangoSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 06:27
Truly sub- human, just like the people who can justify that.
yodeling_YodaSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 07:31
you have to understand there are a lot of hate in China right now, people are getting ripped off by the government (that confiscates their land to build big deparment stores and luxury apartments), by the powerful Rich, and by each other. since your average chinese citizen can't take on the government or the powerful rich, they turn on each other. last time when i visited China i actually witnessed a purse snatching down a street, and immediate you get this crowd running after this one guy lol , i suspect he would have gotten a beaten when he was caught too >_< Remember back in the medieval time how poor villagers throw cabbages? well in china they are a little more advanced.... they throw cement blocks.
ICE420Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 07:35
I wish they had that kind of justice here in the usa.... carefull what ya wish for
ICE420Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 07:47
That was brutal, just sick, the only sub-species of scum that should get that treatment is Paedophile's:mad2:
SkInHoUnDSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 08:26
Now THATS justice.
foreverspeed1984Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 08:29
I love America, please let me stay here for the rest of my life, dont let china invade this country, I love you God !!!
Wirenut420Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 09:08
why didnt they run?ill tell you why. there were numerous ppl all around that u can see in the video.these ppl knows what happens when u steal.should be same way here in usa,because i know what im going to do to you if i catch u stealing my shit! u better hope those chinese ppl get you first!
AbstractSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 09:30
Well, in Iran/Iraq (when Saddam)/Middle east in general they cut your tongue off if they catch you stealing. Or break your arms passing a car over them. Or simply kill you. Of course, no matter what they stole, they did not deserve that; but probably this is the reason why the crimes rate is so low there and in any other place in the world.
emagSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 10:30
I fail to feel sorry for those thieves.
yandaobenSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 11:24
hey, you know, this's happening all over the world. Yes, even in your Aus and US and UK and whatever. the video camera was jus in the right place at the right time to record such an occurence. cmon, unjust human brutality is evident in every friggin society. ghettos...mafias...yakuza...back street brawl, u name it.
Firep0w3rSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 12:42
In America the vigilante idealism was efficently erased in our history. "String 'em up" is no longer the way to deal with alledged theives etc. er...trial by peers, prove them guilty, then punishment seems best. Too many circumstances perhaps unaware of such as a starving family or maybe taking medicine not affordable to substain life. That was just plain cruel.
AvezionSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 14:42
Shit... Never been shoocked by anything on here but that was fucked up.
SolarBearSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 15:32
I wish all thieves were treated this way. No exceptions. If these guys actually stole something, I don't care what it was or why they took it, then they deserved every bit of this beating and more. The problem is, there's no way to know from this video whether they did or not.
kams912Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 15:38
It's hard for most people to understand, but human life is not worth very much in some Countries....
CanadianIdiotSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 19:34
well with a country with a billion people in it, they dont need those kinda things so i guess thats why there so strict
brownbearclanSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 19:40
Well this is why we have HUMAN RIGHTS here in our country. China has no human rights or laws to protect people in situations like this. People can say what they want about the U.S. but I'd live here any day compared to a country where stuff like this is allowed to happen. Has anyone else heard about the bus loads of people China has found to be executing? I also heard that China is #1 in the world as far as number of people executed annually. I wish all thieves were treated this way. No exceptions. If these guys actually stole something, I don't care what it was or why they took it, then they deserved every bit of this beating and more. The problem is, there's no way to know from this video whether they did or not. That is indeed the problem with vigilante style justice. If it were me and the situation were reversed I would want the chance to prove my innocence. Innocent people are still convicted every day though. It's a scary thing being involved with the legal system, but you still a better chance than at the hands of vigilantes.
giantfblSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 19:52
That's what we should do to the mexicans that run across our border! :xyxthumbs: one country! one flag! one language ! Habla?
andrexoteSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 20:13
Idiot ------------- The funny thing here is that, after seeing the vid, the nickelodeon's Kids Choice Award add appeared like nothing...now that was disturbing
supanovazSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 21:34
F#*@ those stupid Cowardly Chinamen, watching this makes me wanna seriously hurt those people, but then i guess I'm no better than they are.Why don't the big crowd do something f#!Kin uncivilized morons
Canibusx420Salvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 21:36
i will never steal from the chinese, garunteed tony jaa was making sure those guys didn't run! I was not surprised to see the extremes of the punishment maybe the mob standing there was motivation to take the beating instead of a mob stomping, I will stick to breaking laws in my own country where i can trust that my human rights will not be violated to that extent
moonbatSalvaged from archive6 Apr 2007, 22:30
We Don't actually know why they got the beating , pretty nasty though , I'm bettin they won't do what ever they did again
diegobobcatSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 00:10
....these are scenes about world going down ! no matter who is right or not....this is how the human are. Sorry for my english, I'm from Italy.
ImbalancedSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 04:08
that was horrific, i can't believe nobody stopped that. i seriously almost just threw up, that was completely barbaric. no human deserves that. that was Hostile-ish... *barf*
travelmanSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 04:17
We Don't actually know why they got the beating , pretty nasty though , I'm bettin they won't do what ever they did again well, it all started out as a friendly argument about britney or shakira being the best singer....and then someone made a joke about britneys new haircut, and well...it just got worse from there....
PuzSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 08:53
Fucking dickheads !!! :mad2: :mad2:
Firep0w3rSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 09:06
Ohh Boy!! you're in for a treat, if you think that's brutal let me introduce you to the videos that change my attitude towards humans and life as i use to know it. First you have to watch "Faces of Death" "Sorry for the long story":o Faces of Death Oh yeah, I rented those back in the mid 80's. Holy shit they were graphic. To this day I will always remember what a man put to death in the Electric Chair looked like as he was cooking......whew
Firep0w3rSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 09:15
That's what we should do to the mexicans that run across our border! :xyxthumbs: one country! one flag! one language ! Habla? pfffftttt... another sick fuck in here. Waiting for your ticket to China?
DriZSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 10:11
What I dont understand -- why didnt they just run? Indeed, steeling is one thing, but how the fuck did they get in the position where they are lying on the ground? I'm sure they had chances to run or w/e. You're not better then them if you fuck 'em up after the crime they commited...
redd_420_20Salvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 10:47
duuuuuuuuuuuuuude!!!!! oh man that was horrible!!! you can bet at least one of them died just from the constant kindney punches and kicks alone. I almost wish I wouldnt have watched that. thats still not as bad as the little girl in africa who was beaten by a mob,set on fire while she was still awake then some brave svage decided to drop about a 150-200lb rock on top of her a couple times. we are talking about a child here. I think thins on might be even harder to watch with all the screaming and moaning going on. remind me not to steal when I goto china
redd_420_20Salvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 10:50
That's what we should do to the mexicans that run across our border! :xyxthumbs: or maybe just shoot them so they dont suffer like that? youd have to be pretty buff to lift a cinder block that many times with the rate there invading us.
redace72374Salvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 12:06
I totally believe in the whole "eye for an eye" theory, but this is overkill. There was no need to beat those thieves with cinderblocks. They should of just chopped off a finger or 2 and called it even.
siguangSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 12:56
fuck!
jonmcc33Salvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 13:37
well at the beginning the two Suspects were on the ground and they were not handcuffed or restrained and there was only one person attacking them; why didn't they fight back or run? You couldn't do this in the U.S. and get away with it; Self Defense and use of Violence to protect your Property can only get you so far. That's what I am saying. If you get caught, run the fuck away. Don't sit there and cry and take a beating. You were given legs for a reason! Still, nowhere close as Muslim countries that cut their freakin' hands off like they are two pieces of steak.
MonstermashSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 15:49
Please explain to me then why, in the Scandinavian countries, where punishments are much more lenient than in the US, and no death penalty, are crime rates far, far lower than in the US? A beating like in this video was highly excessive, and showed exactly what's wrong with vigilante "justice". I'm all for locking up chid molestors and violent murderers for life, but getting beaten within an inch of your life by a mob in vigilante "justice" style for stealing... I'm dismayed to see that there are people that seem OK with it. If that's true that's cool. Often I've thought Sweden is cool. Maybe its the cold weather, it keeps everyone cool :). Those peeps taking a beating maybe very poor and have stolen out of necessity. Are there many people on this forum who are/have been very poor. I have'nt been that poor, but I can imagine that if you don't have enough to get by you will find a way. I think the beating is brutal. OK in the west criminals may have it easy, but let us not return to the dark times or the way things are in other countries where people have their limbs removed because they have stolen or even if you speak out of place and opinion that is not allowed to be stated, this form of punishment is barbarism. We are meant to be the most civilised animal on the planet, but maybe we are not :( Maybe we are the most barbaric animal ever to have evolved into existence.
RuffRydeSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 15:57
thats what i call a beat down but really... those theives are a bunch of sissys!!! why didnt they run or fight back in the beginning? I woulda beat that guy down!!
El DementoSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 17:14
Poetic justice. People commit crimes because they know they'll either get away with it, or have a very minor punishment. Maybe they'll think twice stealing in china. Would you preform that punishment? What if a little girl stole a pack of bubble gum? Would you smash her fingers with concrete blocks? What is so valuable that smashing someones spine or hands with rocks is a apt punishment for?
AsskickerSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 18:53
After seeing liveleak.com and the thieves there, the best solution is to be like Charles Bronson. Don't cause torture, that is wrong. But when it comes to tyrannical survival Charles would just shoot them to put them out of thier's and ours misery. STop the torture and notice that it is the government's fault for allowing the rich to dominate. Then again the rich own the government. Hey there only trying to survive and thus they are being reasonable and justified, all of them. Just thank your government.
ding0Salvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 20:35
See- this is why we shouldn't be in Iraq!!! Americans torturing poor thieves in the streets with... the... oh, not in Iraq? Other countries are screwed up too? See- this is why we shouldn't be in Iraq!!! ...we should be in China instead.
BleedingHeart23Salvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 20:37
I wish they had that kind of justice here in the usa.... Oblivously you are not a true american. If you actually paid attention in your history class you would remember the bill of rights which America is formed on today. Amendment VIII Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted. And yes you are oblivious.
crackymSalvaged from archive7 Apr 2007, 21:24
Wow, this video seems to have really bought out the best and worst of people. On the one hand, we have those who think dropping a cinder block on someones spine for (allegedly) stealing is barbaric. On the other hand, we have those who think that trying to murder someone on the street because they stole some stupid piece of shit you paid for is justified. I wonder if the vid title had been "speeders in china get a disturbing beatdown", would we have seen a different response...
simplelifedreamSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 03:46
Youtube version 84GcKJnE_Ow
Josh85Salvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 07:12
I wouldn't take that shit. Even if there was a mob watching, where is these guys' survival instincts? Fucker picks up a brick or whatever and I'd be up in seconds, trying to kill him before he can throw that thing.
GauzexSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 15:30
give them lashings with a whip, but dont permafuck them
Big OzzieSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 16:08
I heard that they weren't thieves at all, but got the beatdown for bad mouthing FileCabi.Net and the posting members!:eek: :eek:
LeonidasSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 17:17
Culture shock, what works for one may not work for others... We in jabAmerica eat cows and are fat like pig, china men eat dog skinny like porcupine needle - all jabAmericans pay through nose for 10 billion dollars in retail theft, Chinese pay 50 yen for brick. Odds are that the 9999 out of 10000 Chinese videos that don't get published still don't come close to the vile and inhumane things that go on in our own country under our own nose without a second thought but to get it all on tape, then rush home and send it to filecabi just so we can hear someone say "first".
Project PatSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 17:21
......Chinese videos that don't get published still don't come close to the vile and inhumane things that go on in our own country under our own nose without a second thought but to get it all on tape, then rush home and send it to filecabi just so we can hear someone say "first". Don't you live in Sparta? and you are talking about inhumane? :D
RaidenatorSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 18:27
Culture shock, what works for one may not work for others... We in jabAmerica eat cows and are fat like pig, china men eat dog skinny like porcupine needle - all jabAmericans pay through nose for 10 billion dollars in retail theft, Chinese pay 50 yen for brick. Odds are that the 9999 out of 10000 Chinese videos that don't get published still don't come close to the vile and inhumane things that go on in our own country under our own nose without a second thought but to get it all on tape, then rush home and send it to filecabi just so we can hear someone say "first". I've got news for you, vile and inhumane things don't just go on in America. It's every country in the world, so don't single out the US for it.
gloglogloSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 19:18
people seem to think it's cool nowadays to single out the US and say how we suck. If we really sucked we probably wouldn't have the power to wipe you off the planet with one signature and a stealth bomber.
LeonidasSalvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 19:34
people seem to think it's cool nowadays to single out the US and say how we suck. If we really sucked we probably wouldn't have the power to wipe you off the planet with one signature and a stealth bomber. Theres a little joke going on here, can't say what it for fear of being banned for picking on a boy who puts the dig on America every chance gotten.
Canibusx420Salvaged from archive8 Apr 2007, 23:01
I would say the most haunting video I have ever seen was footage from another site of this soldiers head being cut off with a serated (sp?) blade. It was in black and white but you could see the blood and hear the sounds of the cutting it was the most sadistic thing i have ever seen
RaidenatorSalvaged from archive9 Apr 2007, 00:44
Theres a little joke going on here, can't say what it for fear of being banned for picking on a boy who puts the dig on America every chance gotten. There's a little joke for people who like to bash on the U.S. every chance they get too...Is it wrong to love one's own country?
lionheart101Salvaged from archive10 Apr 2007, 11:37
Well this is why we have HUMAN RIGHTS here in our country. China has no human rights or laws to protect people in situations like this. People can say what they want about the U.S. but I'd live here any day compared to a country where stuff like this is allowed to happen. Has anyone else heard about the bus loads of people China has found to be executing? I also heard that China is #1 in the world as far as number of people executed annually. That is indeed the problem with vigilante style justice. If it were me and the situation were reversed I would want the chance to prove my innocence. Innocent people are still convicted every day though. It's a scary thing being involved with the legal system, but you still a better chance than at the hands of vigilantes. The chineese government has admitted that all the people EXECUTED are to have all of their vital organs harvested and sold to anybody that can afford it,The familys of the executed are given no compensation all they recieve is their dead relatives ashes, im sure it was a clip from a bbc documentary that was posted on here, I dont want to sound like a racist but these people are animals!!!:mad2: im sooooo thankfull i live in scotland
Mad MarkSalvaged from archive11 Apr 2007, 20:57
I don't think they'll do that again.
RobTheMonkSalvaged from archive12 Apr 2007, 21:45
Fuck me, that was savage. They mus be dead to be honest, I mean; 1. Loads of knees, kicks and punches to the body, thats ribs broke and internal bleeding at least. 2. Cinder blocks the the base of the spine, legs, hands, head. Broken bones, paralysis, kidney fucked, internal organs fucked. Fucking hell that was nasty shit.
philippoSalvaged from archive3 May 2007, 04:14
It's hard for most people to understand, but human life is not worth very much in some Countries.... Very true,USA is in the lead...I saw many videos of shop robbery in usa when thieves shot saleseman and none of these was discussed so much as this beatdown...sad
cylonraiderSalvaged from archive2 Jun 2007, 06:38
I wish they had that kind of justice here in the usa.... and the uk
bornslippySalvaged from archive6 Jun 2007, 13:16
Please explain to me then why, in the Scandinavian countries, where punishments are much more lenient than in the US, and no death penalty, are crime rates far, far lower than in the US? A beating like in this video was highly excessive, and showed exactly what's wrong with vigilante "justice". I'm all for locking up chid molestors and violent murderers for life, but getting beaten within an inch of your life by a mob in vigilante "justice" style for stealing... I'm dismayed to see that there are people that seem OK with it. Other than gun crime the crime rate in Scandanavia is actually far higher than it is in America.
UnregisteredSalvaged from archive7 Jun 2008, 11:58
have you guys seen the footage of chinese soldiers killing tibetans? just shooting them in the back as they walked through the mountains. there is something very wrong with the nation, if shit like this is acceptable behavior. the government spun it off as they were defending themselves. which is funny as it was videotaped and they were all unarmed. not to say this doesnt happen in the us. there are plenty of cases of unarmed people being shot to death by police, its mentioned in the news, but then you never hear about it again.
mousewallratSalvaged from archive7 Jun 2008, 23:25
I don't give a fuck what they stole.they did not deserve 99 percent of that beating.Those people who hit them with cement blocks are the real criminals and are the ones that should get a beating like that and then some.Bunch of fucking cowards taking advantage of the chance to brutally beat some people. To me this is part of the attitude that is weakening our country. We've become so inured to the idea that a criminal deserves to be treated gently, that we're no longer able to protect our selves, our homes, or our country. If someone were to get caught stealing from me, what these guys got wouldn't look so bad. Taking what I own, and worked so damned hard for, or stealing what those Chinese guys had is equivelant to stealing some portion of thier lives...the portion they used to work for that item. Steal some portion of my life, and expect severe concequences. I think I agree with what they did. And can you deny that if more justice were dished out summarily, like this was, that there would be fewer thieves? Oh, I thought not.
mousewallratSalvaged from archive7 Jun 2008, 23:32
dud do you really think anyone in the US would have stood for that shit ?!?! Dud I would have come back and shot everyone standing there that looked liked the kicked me .. Really......isn't this the same US where a bunch of bar patrons (in New York, if I remember correctly)watched some poor woman get raped on a pool table, and not one miserable sorry motherfucker in the place went to her aid? Yeah, I sort of think it is, which blows your argument out of the water about what Americans would stand for.
SoraellionSalvaged from archive9 Jun 2008, 04:50
Hmm, because a thief who brings a (shot)gun to threaten with or to actually use it should have any rights whatsoever. Not saying that this is the case here but people who steal, attack or kill someone for their personal gain should lose any rights they had. Congrats on the store owner (if that is the case) for making people understand he doesn't like to get mugged.
mousewallratSalvaged from archive9 Jun 2008, 10:06
The proper headline for this vid should be; 'Thieves in China Get Exactly What They Deserve. Isn't Vigilantiism Wonderful!'
psycho_terrorSalvaged from archive9 Jun 2008, 10:14
The proper headline for this vid should be; 'Thieves in China Get Exactly What They Deserve. Isn't Vigilantiism Wonderful!' it wouldn't be so wonderful if he was falsely accused, which is exactly why any civilised country has a criminal justice system in order to deal with these problems.

Reply

Want your old post taken down? Get in touch.